Read other letters about this article
I rented a SmartCar in France several years ago. I've also been renting the Toyota Vitz in Tokyo. I agree with everything the author says about the SmartCar. Its even kind of a shock how nimbly it navigates the city, and European city centers are worse than SF for parking and traffic hands down. However, the Vitz is actually a real car. It can drive on the highway, fit 3 adults and two kids, and handle a medium load with the backseat folded forward. Plus, it's no slouch at city driving either (if you've ever driven in Tokyo you'll know that SF will be a breeze).
Bottom line for me: if the mileage and price of the Vitz and the SmartCar are comparable, the Vitz wins in every category. Plus, Toyota's quality is bulletproof and its cars are generally hassle free.