- Top Features:
- War Room
- Glenn Greenwald
- Broadsheet
- Joan Walsh
- Camille Paglia
- Since You Asked
- Follow Salon:
Read other letters about this article
Regarding my previous claim that the 9/11 truthers need to come off as reasonable, not loony, here's an example:
You need to get off the fence paulpsd7. Both stories can't be correct any more than both stories can be incorrect.
Um, I don't know what limited reality you occupy, but in fact both stories can indeed be incorrect. If your worldview on 9/11 is limited solely to either the fact that 19 Muslim terrorists did it, or the Bush Administration did it, with absolutely no overlap between these two, and no possibility of any other options, then that says more about you than it does about 9/11. If, say, in a couple years time, President Obama starts hearing arguments like these to supporpt request to reopen the investigation, he'll look like a fool if he treats them seriously.
As to the Bush Administration's incompetence,while their socio/economic incompetence is beyond dispute, that image largely stems from the imbecile known as Bush. Bush didn't need to carry out the attack or plan it: they have the Pentagon and the CIA for that.
So, are you saying that Bush personally botched FEMA's response at Katrina, or that he personally botched the Iraq invasion? Meaning, he was there on the ground, running the show, and making bad decisions? Either that or you need to concede that it was the Bush Administration at large that was responsible for these fuckups, the exact same people you bestow omnipotence on for what they carried out on 9/11.
Flipping it over, you need to look at what you do believe- that a bunch of Saudi students from Hamburg, who could hardly fly a plane performed feats of military-style flying that only skilled and experienced pilots could possibly have performed.
While that indeed sounds implausible, compared to the notion that the Bush Administration scripted and executed a plan flawlessly, requiring the cooperation of hundreds of people to attack their own country and then remain perfectly silent about it, to me the Arab terrorist story sounds far more likely. Sorry.
NOTHING about 9/11 has actually been investigated since the 9/11 Commission was purely a PR exercise and as such was yet another scandalous waste of taxpayers' money.
On this we agree. However, in order for our government (once it's headed by someone not overwhelmingly malevolent) to reopen this investigation, they need to hear well-founded arguments, not absurd ones. The best thing all the 9/11 truthers can do to further this cause is to get the rhetoric in line with reason. Do not pretend to know things you could not know. Do not jump to radical conclusions. Just take what is currently known, and point to where it doesn't add up. That much is easy. Then, get an investigative panel with subpoena power to do the rest.
I know, none of this is easy. But it's really the only way forward. Otherwise, the 9/11 truthers will be marginalized like the flat earth society. And that would be tragic.
