- Top Features:
- War Room
- Glenn Greenwald
- Broadsheet
- Joan Walsh
- Camille Paglia
- Since You Asked
- Follow Salon:
Read other letters about this article
Good heavens! That filesharing has spread in popularity and variety as rapidly as it has, such that days before the last Harry Potter book is available in stores it's already to be found on torrent sites: this is, in fact, newsworthy. Maybe not front-page news, but as part of tech blog? Certainly.
Filesharing isn't going to go away if people shut their ears and stop talking about it. Reporting the existence of a "Deathly Hallows" torrent isn't spoiling or ruining anything, unless you imagine that Rowling or Scholastic are going to cancel all orders and burn every copy of the book in a fit of pique. It'll still be for sale in stores in a few days.
The report does have an irreverent, possibly even pro-filesharing slant to it, but that's no cause for a blanket condemnation or speculation of criminal liability. Drawing moral equivalence between discussing the existence of filesharing and filesharing itself is absurd. If I write a report about a murder, am I giving up my right to be murdered? That seems to be the tenor of some arguments.
