Letters posted here are associated with the following article:

8
Letters
Tuesday, November 3, 2009 12:00 AM

Illegal immigration -- India-style

Chinese laborers sneak into the subcontinent to work on big construction projects. But who is being exploited?

The letters thread is now closed.

View:
Tuesday, November 3, 2009 12:12 PM

"They'll set up this plant in 15 months whereas a plant of a similar nature would take an Indian enterprise eight years," he says. D.S. Rajan, director, Centre for China Studies, Chennai, agrees on that point. "

Thanks Andrew, wasn't aware of this!

India has long had a command economy and those few who get government jobs enjoy a great deal of perks which can be worth several times the base salary.

Despite the number of people without work who eke out a living in the informal economy, it takes Indians many more days to load ships, for example, which hurts India's export industries.

To get around this unionized work environment, the Indians have obviously hired itinerant Chinese who don't enjoy labor protections in their own country and are just interested in an $$$ salary they can send home.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 01:19 PM

Sounds familiar.

This sounds a lot like an American oil services compound in an oil country. A lot of amenities that aren't avalable on the economy and much higher wages than at home. I wonder if the Chinese get a tax break, too.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 01:33 PM

is this really a new phenomenon?

Isn't this standard operating procedure for lots of construction projects around the world? The Chinese workers are not just temporary workers, they are temporary workers who will almost certainly not wish to stay when this one particular job is done. And even the "unskilled" workers on the site have one key skill: they speak the same language as the skilled workers.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 02:13 PM

Outsourced Journalism

Isn't that what blogging is? After all, Mr. Leonard probably commands a higher salary than the unnamed author of the investigation for India's "Outlook" which he picked up from a secondary source (CDT) - they even wrote opening paragraphs he aspires to.

Perhaps Salon should stop allowing its bloggers to profit off the derivative use of the work and creativity of others and merely have editors who choose to pay for first source foreign journalism.

Schadenfreude? More like living in glass houses with a bowl of stones.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 02:39 PM

@ tangerinespeedo

I'm not so sure i would put our dear HTWW author at the high end of the journalistic pay scale....

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 04:17 PM

Andrew, you're not getting out much these days?

Africans have been howling about this for years with infrastructure projects the Chinese are building in exchange for exclusive mineral rights - all the plum, and crucial, jobs are being performed by Chinese labor.

Long gone are the days when you just throw a few thousand pick-ax and wheel barrow wielding coolies at a project when a couple hundred semi-skilled people who can handle heavy machinery can get the job done in a much shorter time, and they are still paid shitty wages (by Western standards).

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 05:55 PM

The Chinese companies winning these contracts are government owned, though that means by a specific ministry or province rather than being coordinated from some central office in Beijing.

And they bring their own labor with them to do the job. The onslaught of Chinese workers in Vietnam, where Middle Kingdom firms have nabbed numerous infrastructure project contracts, has created a xenophobic reaction based on a history of the Chinese hanging around.

Wednesday, November 4, 2009 11:10 PM

Illegal immigration is a global problem???

So you're saying we should in-source politicians from Finland to solve our illegal immigration problems!

I'm with that!

.. if only.

Most Active Letters Threads

530

Do Obama officials know what his Afghanistan plan is?

What explains the completely contradictory statements from key aides on a central plank of the war strategy?
307

A new report questions "suicides" at Guantanamo

Why is the Obama DOJ attempting to block judicial review of three highly suspicious deaths?
245

I live in a van down by Duke University

How do I afford grad school without going into debt? A '94 Econoline, bulk food and creative civil disobedience
128

Is my kids making me not smart?

Stay-at-home fatherhood dulls my intellect to a nub. Excuse me while I ponder the subtext of "Hippos Go Berserk"
126

Trig, the anti-abortion straw baby

Sarah Palin's son is being used to demonize pro-choicers

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon