Letters to the Editor

This letter is associated with the following article:
What does it take to make a plane fly? Can it take off from a conveyor belt? The pilot weighs in on an old brainteaser.
  • No Airspeed = No Takeoff

    Aerodynamic lift is how standard airplanes take off.

    "To generate lift, an object must move through the air, or air must move past the object. [Some modern aircraft like the Harrier use engine thrust to "lift" the vehicle. But this, again, is not aerodynamic lift.]"

    http://wright.nasa.gov/airplane/move.html

    In the case of the reverse treadmill the airplane remains stationary in relation to the air so it stays on the ground. Wheel speed is not relevant.

    OTOH a forward moving treadmill could do much in making takeoffs more interesting and restoring the gee-wiz factor to aviation. Sort of like the catapult on a aircraft carrier but much more massive.

    If such a project could somehow be related to homeland security I am sure the contracts would already be in Halliburton's hands...