Letters to the Editor

This letter is associated with the following article:
A discussion with Andrew Wilkow about that "trick question" on abortion.
  • A different Hypothetical

    Here's a different question which is perhaps less emotionally charged:

    If the pro-life side actually believes that a fetus is a life the same as a living child, then why has the SD lawstipulated only a five year prison sentence for doctors who perform abortions and nothing for the mother or other accomplices (like who ever drove her to the clinic)?

    Does the pre-meditated "murder" of a "child" warrant only a five year sentence?

    If a mother and father hired a hitman to smother their week old baby, would the only criminal sanction be a five year jail sentence for the hitman and nothing for the parents?