Read other letters about this article
"In the certitude of ethical heaven, you needn't worry about such things."
Your scenarios are constructed in ethical heaven, where knowlege is absolute. As you say, we don't live there. In fact--there is no "there".
So regardless of how one would answer your question, it has no bearing on the programmatic use of illegal torture here--in this world--of flesh, blood, dogs, darkness, and feces.