Read other letters about this article
I don't see the problem with judging the guy's record, which includes the cases he decided to take, when deciding whether or not you support the appointment.
Sure. I simply disagree with what you see as a "blemish". I don't see it that way. To me, the client is one thing, and the attorney is another. The law, as I understand it, depends upon a vigorous defense. It is absolutely critical. Regardless of the specific client or case.
This is bedrock stuff, imo.