Letters to the Editor

Letters posted here are associated with the following article:
The FBI's emerging, leaking case against Ivins The more revelations there are in the Bruce Ivins case, the more questions there are.
The letters thread is now closed.
  • sorry ready1, I dont quite see your point.

    But I think it is in there somewhere. Is it something like "Matsumoto was working with the establishment, and so it shows that the political establishment regarded Ivins as a major pain because he wouldn't play ball with them?"

  • If that is the point,

    Then Ivins' situation is starting to sound like the Valerie Plame situation. Oh No!. Who would have thunk it?

  • Don't forget yesterday's ALL THINGS CONSIDERED

    On Tuesday August 5, my son was driving me home from work & he wanted to know why I questioned whether the FBI had really discovered the correct killer in the anthrax inquiry. The NPR report that spawned my derision was one noting that in Dr. Ivins's senior high class play, he played (cue the creepy music) a murderer. I don't know whether NPR dug up that irrelevant gem itself or whether that's courtesy of an FBI leak, but c'mon. As I pointed out to my son, HE played the people-eating plant in his high school's production of LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORS. That doesn't mean 30 years from now, he'll be a cannibal.

    I know NPR isn't always everything I'd like it to be, but this is sinking below Fox News levels. It may be worth noting that at least one professional infectious diseases group urges skepticism about the anthrax case's closure. NPR would have done better to note that than to blither away about Ivins's high school play.

  • Aha! I knew I recognized the profile of Ivins from somewhere!

    It's that same one they used for Valerie Plame!

  • Query

    Did theripist Duley go to Sturgis this week? Now there's a lady who qualifies for a snitching job given her background.

    My God, it hurts me to see what bikers have become. And as if that wasn't bad enough, now Republicans. You guys all saw the video of McCain offering up Cindy (who was right next to him) as a contestant in the "Miss Buffalo Chip" Topless Beauty contest at Sturgis, right? That woman is made of stone, man, frickin' granite! Sure, she's a wet blanket, but think of the keggers you could hold!

  • By did the FBI ever make a mockery

    of that little paper they are sworn to uphold. I guess we wont see Ivin's "confronted with hte witnesses against him " anytime soon.

    Amendment VI

    In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the assistance of counsel for his defense.

    The Bill of Rights, of The United States Constitution

  • Full disclosure is inevitable, I suppose.

    Regarding Glenn Greenwald's comments about Ed Lake and secret identities, he does have a point. However, Ed Lake's articles mostly revolve around trying to promote the theory of "low tech anthrax", in the face of AFIP and USAMRIID scientists, as well as the authoritative reporting of Richard Preston (the Hot Zone) and Gary Matsumoto on the issue - and he has no background in the subject.

    Basically, my limited expertise in this area stems from my scientific background, most of which involves the role of microbes in the environment and in industry. My real interests are global climate change and renewable energy, say the use of microbes to convert cellulose to ethanol, or atmospheric nitrogen to plant fertilizer.

    I also have a long-standing side interest in limiting the expansion of biological warfare agents and antibiotic-resistant microbes, and have read most every popular science text on the subject and a bit of the technical literature as well.

    I much prefer the issues of renewable energy and global warming, quite frankly. Fossil fuel executives are, after all, currently working to provide energy for people all over the world, and it's just unfortunate that their products lead to global warming - but once everyone sees that renewables are also profitable (and don't trash the planet), the transition will occur.

    However, these freaks in the biowarfare and nuclear warfare business don't listen to reason, as this whole nasty anthrax episode shows. Still, this business really cannot be allowed to continue - and here's why, quoted straight from Ken Alibek, the Soviet Biopreparat researcher. First, consider Sverdlovsk:

    "On the last Friday of March 1979, a technician in the anthrax drying plant at Compound 19, a biological arms production facility in Sverdlovsk, scribbled a quick note for is supervisor before going home. "Filter clogged so I've removed it. Replacement necessary..."

    ...when the night shift manager came on duty, he scanned the logbook. Finding nothing unusual, he gave the command to start the machines up again. A fine dust containing anthrax spores and chemical additives swept through the exhaust pipes into the night air...

    ...The Soviet Union later claimed that 96 people were stricken with the disease and 66 died. The scientist who was working in the Sverdlovsk facility at the time told me the death toll was 105... What is certain is that it was the worst single outbreak of inhalational anthrax on record this century."

    At the time, the West had no idea that the Biopreparat program existed, due to the extreme secrecy on the Soviet side. This exposure was supposed to lead to more transparency and a shutdown of the Soviet biowarfare program, and expansion of international anti-biowar treaties.

    Reading about this in 2000, I recall thinking "Thank God that's all in the past - no more state biowarfare programs, just your ineffective lone nuts sprinkling Salmonella on salad bars. What a relief."

    It is now fairly apparent, however, that Alibek's defection to the U.S. led to a "catch-up" mentality within some sectors of the U.S. military during the 1990s - and some people saw that biowarfare fears could be quite profitable, as well.

    Consider what noted journalist Laurie Garrett had to say about biowarfare tests (pg 501, Betrayal of Trust):

    "A year later officials from the Pentagon, several other federal agencies, and the New York City government would role-play an anthrax terrorism event. In their scenario somebody placed aerosolizers inside Grand Central Station at rush hour, releasing anthrax spores. Two weeks later in this scenario Gotham was a ghost town because millions had fled in panic, antibiotic supplies were long since depleted, more than a million people were dead or ailing, the NYSE had collapsed, and law and order had broken down."

    This is a topic that goes undiscussed, unbelievably enough - what if the letter writer had taken 10 grams of anthrax spores and done that instead of mailing them in carefully taped envelopes - that leaked anyway? Just opening one envelope in the Hart Office Building was enough to infect 30 people - that's a weaponized anthrax preparation.

    The way to prevent things like this from happening again is to expand the scope of international biowarfare treaties, especially their transparecy and compliance sections - another topic that the press has refused to touch. I thought that the Sunshine Project was keeping tabs on this, but some time I ago I discovered they had shut down due to lack of funds. Great.

    In any case, everything I've said I've referenced to authoritative sources - so if you want to attack those sources, go ahead and good luck. If you want to know who I am and what I normally focus on, just go to Google and type in the following:

    site:www.realclimate.org "ike solem"

    qualifications to comment on technical issues?

    B.S. Biochemistry and Molecular Biology

    M.S. Ocean Sciences in area of marine microbiology

    NSF Graduate Student Fellowship (Microbiology) 1998-2001

    you can also email me at ike_solm@hotmail.com

    (publishers and agents only please!)

Most Active Stories

Read More

Letters Help

Daily Delivery

Salon headlines in your mailbox