This letter is associated with the following article:
Letters
Tuesday, November 6, 2007 12:00 AM

The Ron Paul phenomenon

An unconventional, anti-Beltway presidential candidacy is understandably igniting genuine political passion.

Read other letters about this article

Tuesday, November 6, 2007 03:16 PM

More Ill-Informed Confusion

scottfrost:

Ron Paul has argued against racism. He is on record saying that it is collectivist nonsense. He should get the benefit of the doubt.

That's not an argument against racism. That's an argument against "collectivism" and a form of denial that he and his kind could possibly be racists.

Furthermore, it's an easily refuted view. The National Election Survey asks a number of relevant questions, most notably, it asks people about their feelings towards different groups, including Blacks, using a temperature scale from 1-100, as well as asking about their policy views. There is a consistent correlation between more negative views of blacks and opposition to "collectivist" positions. For example (each of the three categories is about 1/3 of the population +/- 4%):

Strongly favoring a government insurance health plan:

0-50% Temp: 16.9
51-75% Temp: 16.3
76-100% Temp: 24.2

Strongly favoring Government seeing to job and good standard of living:

0-50% Temp: 7.2
51-75% Temp: 6.8
76-100% Temp: 18.2

Increase Federal Spending On Poor/Poor People:

0-50% Temp: 43.2
51-75% Temp: 53.1
76-100% Temp: 63.5

Increase Federal Spending On Child Care:

0-50% Temp: 50.0
51-75% Temp: 53.4
76-100% Temp: 65.4

In short, the less you like blacks, the less "collectivist" you are. The exact opposite of how Paul characterizes racism--thus proving conclusively that it's "collectivism" he opposes, not racism.

It is also worth noting that he never advocates any policies which disproportionatley benefit one group at the expense of another. He clearly insists that all people have equal rights.

That's what he claims. But what if you look at who benefits from the things he opposes? Then the picture will clearly show he opposes programs that benefit Blacks and Latinos. But that's all just coincidence, right?

I'm just waiting to hear that some of his best friends are black.

Most Active Letters Threads

650

The pitbull in lipstick is back!

She's "tired of hearin' the talk talk talk" but Palin wowed Tea Party Nation Inc. with nastiness for fun and profit
511

Wall Street owners angry with their purchase

Bankers threaten to once again fund the GOP if Obama continues saying mean things about them
387

Palin and the tea-party "movement": nothing new

After Bush/Cheney, the GOP needs a new branding campaign and this is what they've found
266

Rich Lowry's brain

The capacity of the right-wing mind to attack exactly that which it does is apparently infinite
175

"Marry Him!": Settling and the single girl

Lori Gottlieb talks about her controversial dating book, which has some women foaming and Hollywood courting

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon