Read other letters about this article

• Sunday, October 7, 2007 07:35 AM

  Dave, Downing Street Memo? El Pais?

  Ignatius is nothing if not a dutiful stenographer for bush admin. propaganda. That's no surprise. What's stunning is that he could come out with this kind of column in the immediate aftermath of the El Pais article containing the transcript of bush's conversation with Aznar. Didn't that remind Ignatius that administration talk of "striving to avoid" war is complete bullshit?

  But Dave is there to take notes, not practice journalism. Here's one of my favorite Ignatius columns, from Oct. 7, 2002.

  Many analysts warn of the disasters that await in this postwar Iraq, but frankly I'm not convinced. Yes, Iraq is a country with many ethnic groups that don't always get along. And, yes, there will be a risk of revenge killings and general mayhem as the millions of Iraqis who suffered from Hussein's torturers seek to settle scores.

  But these strike me as manageable problems, especially if people think carefully about them beforehand. Maintaining order will be essential in the first weeks and months after Hussein and his secret police are gone, and Washington should be training military police who will keep the peace, even as it drills the soldiers who will do the fighting. Yet we hear little of these plans -- even though they would encourage Iraqis and other Arabs, and even Europeans, to feel that the war is worth fighting.

  In truth, Iraq is probably more ready for democracy than any nation in the Arab world. That's partly because its people have suffered so much from the cruelty of the current regime. But it's also because the Iraqis are the most likely Arabs to build a truly modern nation. For centuries, Baghdad has been a center of learning, and the Iraqis gained a reputation as the Prussians of the Arab world. It was no accident that Iraq was the only Arab country with the scientific brainpower to mount a serious nuclear weapons program.

  And the talk of Iraq's internecine strife is overblown, too. The long-repressed Shiite community forms a majority of its population, which leads some analysts to fear Shiites will create a radical Muslim regime. But the Shiites of Iraq are Arabs who stayed loyal to Hussein through nearly a decade of war against the Persians of Iran. Iraq's Shiite elite has been the country's leading modernizers, supplying more than their share of scientists and engineers.

  Every other column from Ignatius in those days came straight from Wolfowitz's hard drive. Post-war strike between sunnis and shiites? Nah,

  —thomas c Read thomas c's other letters
  Permalink
  Flag
  Click "Submit Flag" if you feel this post is inappropriate. Explain why below if you wish.

  Cancel