Letters posted here are associated with the following article:

259
Letters
Saturday, September 29, 2007 12:00 AM

Fox News' attack on the honor and integrity of our war generals

Fox accuses the generals of "betraying" their own soldiers and putting their reputations and careers ahead of the lives of U.S. soldiers.

The letters thread is now closed.

View:
Sunday, September 30, 2007 09:41 AM

I got to go hit the turnpike!

It's past noon and a good deal of may be missed somewhere else. The morning was dealing with some complicated thinking personages.

I no like to denounce other and call them immature things like, 'cow-paddy' whilst they go thunk, 'funk-you' Glenn. A considerable number of folk need to literally Shrink they stink so.

If a quarrel ensues when I'm out on the road, i hope to Hibernate with a lover. When severely bruised or knifed, I'll get slightly wounded.

It is time to marshal people who will parade the GOP's dirty pink undies.

shilleia men have a dark-headquarters of killing Rifle-Corp in the White House.

This however, must be prevented. If not, a human can try to cross a road,

and a fly-toad's poop, flops. The ring-leaders need to disperse 'um so funky. Keep them in front of the mirror.

Send them away in straight-jacket immediately for they don't know what they are doing.

Call the World Court together.

No, the 'insurrection' can't be suppressed?

But Happily, the dreadful noon will come and go.

The confusion is preparation for peace and tranquility.

Not since the last war did so many confused people appear so damn dead.

Sunday, September 30, 2007 09:46 AM

and it's not only a nice tune, but you can play it!

go to any keyboard. it's just a descending scale. cbAgfEdcEee (the caps double length) and the "new and improved" Garry Owen is getting ready to resume speaking to me!

Sunday, September 30, 2007 09:52 AM

Oh Shugh, I never stopped speaking to you

Did I?

I've always got your "six" and I know you've got mine. So stop worrying about it.

Sunday, September 30, 2007 09:53 AM

i listen, bop, i don't quite understand

(i was never in war). but i listen.

Sunday, September 30, 2007 09:57 AM

Here's a "midi" file of the tune, along with some lyrics

Grab a GUINNESS stout, or maybe two, and sing along.

http://www(dot)contemplator.com/ireland/gowen.html

Sunday, September 30, 2007 10:09 AM

Thanks Gary Owen.

I was in the First of 1/12 Cav. (airmobile) D- company. A platoon soldier who was my favorite black-brother was from Watts.

We called him Frag Man. He was not a so called pro-war killer. He's seen Watts burn.

He's talk and do the dap. When in the rear, and that was rare: Most of the time we'd get logged each 3-4 days with 60- pounds of water, ammo, and leer-packs of dry food. We'd cook with hunks of C- 4.

Frag Man and I were in a all nigh firefight one night. He's do frag air Burst.

Frag Man would go a one, a two, a three, a four! BANG with a air burst foe max metal spreads. FRAG MAN would grieve when someone was hurt, and lost it, and to witness a broken man bundle into a fetal ball. Cry!

O, to promote war and play a rag-fiddle is confusion, galore, and I say slop in the blood, or shut up. O, play a banjo, love jazz, blow a clarinet, kiss Hillary, no-inhale with wild old Billy. Well, rather!

Delve into dippy land and say with Gary Owen, Frag Man and sugarman report to two Toad Warts, GWB and General Petrayus. Yes neonuts sir!

I never knew what ever happened to Frag Man, dead or alive, 60% of my company were wiped-out in the firefights along the Cambodian border.

Frag Man did get put in for a Silver Star that one scary night. No time to star gaze in a fight for your Life when the grind gets like that.

Sunday, September 30, 2007 10:12 AM

re: david sugarman

KB4Hire, the reason people with contrary opinions are slurred is that GG is just short for Great God. same for "concern troll" (thanks for the def). it's merely a paranoid exclusionary principle, made to ensure that everyone thinks alike.

I've been reading various posts of yours on other threads on Salon.com for quite a while now and as always, I really have no idea just what in the hell you are talking about.

At first, I thought it was your lack of capitalization, then I thought maybe you enjoyed a little liquid refreshment or a puff or two while reading Salon.

Now, honestly I mostly just ignore what you write.

Sunday, September 30, 2007 10:14 AM

But Surely...

It hasn't seemed clear to some that FOX was criticizing the military for *not being hawkish enough* and not *not being neocon enough*, in the spirit of Vietnam-era "we didn't really try to win" conservative apologists. It is just the right wing setting up a paper trail for blaming someone besides themselves for the awful and unconscionable disaster in Iraq (and Afghanistan).

What I remain confused about is Greenwald's attitude about the attack - does he support FOX in making it the way he might have the MoveOn attack? Surely the most appropriate time for discussion, both rational (and, as allowed by the constitution) and irrational, on the role of the military and how it is functioning is during a war? In a functional democracy you'd have countless idiots (as at FOX) weighing in on what's going wrong, and maybe some sane voices, too.

And the real issue is what congress is willing to *do* about all this, rather than what type of political speech they are willing to condemn. This is the old shell game where we (the people) believe there is real discussion, when in fact there isn't, about what should and can be done about all this. Fortunately free market economics has taken the place of any diversity of ideology, so you can bet it will "sort itself out" just like the Katrina disaster did...

Sunday, September 30, 2007 10:25 AM

gosh! three tough, war friends

[warning: rambling follows] all in one day! (makes me feel SECURE (nice to feel secure)) seriously, i would have LOVED the army - the comradeship and trust of it. i am envious of you to this day. But i would have been one of those who would have gotten PTSD and would have been a drunk (already, without, i have inclinations that way) - not ever being able to tolerate REMEMBERING. i couldn't have handled it, mentally, even had i come back intact physically. it is necessary to have people who are willing to go through Hell. but i can only accept it if it is Survival. not money. or pride. i'll say something NO ONE will agree with. i am PROUD of israel. they easily could go crazy and kill everyone. but they don't. amazing self restraint. people who never knew war are deciding on it. this is wrong. it REALLY is something you can only know if you were there (but with a good intention to learn, locutus, you can attempt). madelaine albright said, "why do we have such a big army and not use it?" this is typical of those who never went. "use" it. think about it. "use it". since i'm in one of my rare reflective moods, i want to apologize to Retired Military Patriot. i blamed the people who, even now, volunteer. i think they are part of the problem. but they are STUCK there. it's a REALLY difficult problem, garry. we need soldiers. we need soldiers to protect us. but we don't want this war. it isn't NECESSARY. it was just pride and money. it confuses all of us. and it must be so FRUSTRATING to you and RMP and Kitt and bop. generally i just take care of my wife and children. i can do that. but sometimes i think of something larger. i'm at sea then. after all, it's fine that i convinced my boys not to enlist - the army isn't going to fall apart for lack of two. but what if everyone did that? no, it's not Imagine, others, our enemies, WON'T. they will convince their boys to join instead. and they will find the same comradeship and adrenalin and thrill - and suffer later, but what about US? we need to be protected against them. well, it's not just me. the entire world has had this problem and the same bad solution for the past forever. but WE don't NEED Iraq.

Most Active Letters Threads

674

Obama's exceedingly familiar justifications for escalation

The "new" approach to Afghanistan touted by White House officials seems quite old
543

The crazy, irrational beliefs of Muslims

Tom Friedman explains the real problem: stupid Muslims think the U.S. is about war and aggression.
439

The face of rotted Washington

Evan Bayh demands more debt-financed war - fought by others - while boasting that he's a stern "deficit hawk."
212

Yes, it's Obama's war now

An uninspiring speech sells a dubious policy, but progressives who feel betrayed have only themselves to blame
209

Bigotry wins in Switzerland

By voting to ban the construction of minarets, Switzerland apes the most extreme intolerance in the Muslim world

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon