- Top Features:
- War Room
- Glenn Greenwald
- Broadsheet
- Joan Walsh
- Camille Paglia
- Since You Asked
- Follow Salon:
Read other letters about this article
I often agree with Glenn's criticisms of the Bush administration, but as a journalism critic he is often all wet. The post above about the O'Donnell/Leahy interview is one of those times. I say this even though I am much more sympathetic to Leahy's case here than to that of the White House,
What O'Donnell did was to quote the White House position to Leahy and challenge him to respond. She did not endorses it as her own, and that is clear from the context. This is a common journalistic technique when covering political antagonists -- "Mr. X, your opponent, says such-and-such about this matter. What do you say back?" And, after watching to the YouTube video several times, I completely disagree with Glenn's characterization that she was asking the questions "angrily."
It is just as much O'Donnell's job to get into Leahy's face and ask aggressive questions as it is to get into Tony Snow's face and do so.
