Letters to the Editor

This letter is associated with the following article:
Suing George W. Bush: A bizarre and troubling tale U.S. officials went to extremes to stifle our legal challenge to Bush's warrantless surveillance -- but a federal judge says the program is criminal, anyway.
  • @ robert lewis

    Quote:

    "Patrick Henry said it best: Give me liberty, or give me Death."

    Actually, Patrick Henry didn't say it best, because Patrick Henry arguably didn't say it.

    Mr. William Wirt, who published Henry's speech 18 years after the fact, attributed the quote to Henry and his source for it was not Henry, or Henry's writings, but a Judge who orally recounted his memories of the speech to Wirt.

    Henry's devotion to the principle of liberty has been questioned by some scholars who note that, despite the stirring words, Henry retained his slaves following the revolution. What they don't acknowledge, or consider (I say, tongue half in cheek) is that Henry/Wirt says "Give ME liberty," which, like most political speech/acts, centers entirely around the self.

Most Active Stories

Read More

Letters Help

Daily Delivery

Salon headlines in your mailbox