Letters to the Editor

This letter is associated with the following article:
The current spotlight on China's human rights record fails to illuminate its cruel and inhumane treatment of dogs and cats.
  • Hey Dick

    You've never heard of it because most people don't think their lines of reasoning through to the very end.

    Think about it--pro-life and animal rights is all about empathy and suffering. If a partial human fetus could have a similar ability to suffer as a complete chicken (and could you really prove it doesn't? No, you can't), then you can't dodge the issue by claiming that a fetus is just an egg laid by a "companion" chicken. The argument isn't about the COMPLETENESS of a being, it's about "does _________ have the ability to feel pain or suffer?"

    Sure, there's nothing that says you can't care about both people and animals, so there's no inherent conflict there. BUT, if you're really putting the "rights" of an animal above the "rights" of a fetus, that's just plain misanthropy.

    Have to make clear again that I'm NOT pro-life. I'm genuinely curious as to how fundamentalists of the left and right get around their black and white rulings in a morally grey world.