Read other letters about this article
The real value of the torturing of innocents is the psychological value for the citizens back home. Jose Padilla was meant to be the 'foreign' American that would open the door to holding regular American citizens as 'enemy combatants'. And no one would want to resist their 'leader' knowing what the results could be.
Torture is of no benefit in stopping a purported terror attack. The Bush croneys have started to believe their own lies. Either that or Scalia is watching too much 24.