Read other letters about this article
Great post.
I often wonder about the Salon writers and editors after they've provoked. Does it please them? Do they second-guess or are they perpetually happy with their choices? At least Ms. Walsh replied, however perfunctorily. I've longed pined for a dialogue between the Salon staff and its readers. In the past, Mr. Greenwald, Mr. Kaufman, and Ms. Walsh have engaged their readers. I just wish Ms. Walsh would have channeled her past here and responded more fully, given that Ms. Kaplan's essay especially agitated Salon's readership.