Letters to the Editor
-
Cary, that response was uncalled for
Euthanizing an animal is a difficult decision, and there are no clearcut guidelines. The LW doesn't need another guilt trip. Caring for an animal is an entirely differnt ethical proposition from caring for a human being. It has nothing to do with the war in Iraq.
LW, I would talk to a veterinarian before you do anything else. From what you say, the dog might not be in good health. (Eleven is fairly old for some dogs, and the problems you mention might indicate cancer or diabetes.) If the incontinence and the weight problem can be dealt with, the vet will let you know. After the animal is gone, there's no changing your mind, so listen carefully to the vet. From there you can decide what would be in the best interests of the animal.
It's been my sad duty to take responsibility for euthanizing terminally ill pets. Deciding on the time for an animal's death is heartbreaking, but the procedures are humane. I sat with my boyfriend's mother during her final days of cancer, and I've also assisted my vet in euthanizing my cat at the end of her battle with it. If I could choose a way to go, I'd rather go out the way the cat did.
To conflate animal euthanasia with indifference to human suffering is intellectually narcissistic, however. Cary, if you are so concerned about suffering, why not go out and do some actual good in the world? I'm sure there is a school or hospital or homeless shelter that would love to have you volunteer.