Letters posted here are associated with the following article:

50
Letters
Tuesday, October 31, 2006 12:00 AM

No punishment too severe?

States are enacting stricter penalties for convicted sex offenders, but some restrictions may have unintended consequences.

The letters thread is now closed.

View:
Monday, December 4, 2006 12:39 AM

Police and Courts staff seem to Support Girls Lying about Rape, Sex Assault, Pimping and Sex Crimes.

In our current society and public life, girls lie about so much more than just being pregnant to trick a man into staying with them. Imagine yourself dating a girl and finding out about her real age. Imagine sleeping with a girl and then having her cry rape. Imagine a girl paying for dinner or your new xbox 360 and when you break up with her, she accuses you of pimping her.

Come on folkes we live in the real world. When a girl lies, it means nothing to the public. I mean she is a poor, innocent, soft, delicate woman, right?

and men are seen as manipulative user type assholes, right?

I make this point because there are alot of men sitting in jail right now, wishing that they have not taken a chance on a girl who would tell a lie on them, when they started to PMS. Men that become victims of women lying are laughed at by you and the general public. They are seen as, "they get what they ask for" if your going to be a player, then take what goes with it

But no man thinks he is ever going to be acused of rape or a sex crime. After watching the Dateline NBC story on male preditors anyone charged with a sex crime is automatically guilty in the eyes of the public and the media.

Now for gods sake if the guys is innocent, the shame and humiliation has already destroyed his family life and future chances of a decent job in the community. I know what your thinking, if he has a good lawyer, and he's really innocent, he should be able to prove that in court. Well come on, that bull#### and you know it.

If a girl lies to police, she will surely come to court, put her hand on the bible and lie in court. Would you really risk stopping and admitting that you lied about the whole crime? We live in a save yourself world, and no one would do that. Now, if it can be proven that she lied under oath, in court, what brave prosecutor or police official, wants to be seen as charging sweet innocent becky for purgery? They will let her go with what they call a "inconsistant statement" or simply put, she can't recall or doesn't remember at this time. So chances are the case is dropped, and the guy has to go back and face his life, his family, and the shame of his community.

The funny thing is, it doesn't make the splashy headlines of the media around the world

Hey, I have a very controversal idea, why not come up with a registry system on the internet for girls who lie in court or just set men up.

It would be a place where men could go and tel their stories. I know what your thinking, what if someone post something that isn't true about a girl.

God this is the internet, that's never happened before.

how come you can go on the internet and find out rumors about your favorite stars, and there is nothing they can do about it... Imagine if you met a girl at a club and became really serious about her, but started to see some really moody behavioral patterns, you know, fits of anger, i'm sorry, i love you, i hate you..You know, nutty stuff that would leave you to a violent domestic conclusion.

Well, you could simply just jump in front of your google, type in her name, and hear some guys story of how she almost put him away in jail, for an imaginary beating that did not happen.

Hey, i did say that this was controversial and hey, to deal with the nay sayers up front I am not a victim of this crime and no I don't think all women are bad, and I think only proven girls should be posted on the internet.

I truly believe that everyone has the right to tell their story in a free and open society without threats of being sued. Imagine if someone told you ahead of time, that there was a whole in the house that you were about to buy? but got sued for warning you...? basically what i'm saying, is a life is a life, and if a girl is willing to lie under oath to put a guy in jail, I would love to know more about her, so I can stay the hell away.

Well I've said my peace, go ahead let me have it, but first let me put my helmit on.

Thursday, November 2, 2006 03:09 PM

Cayetana

Isn't whether a sex crime has been committed up to the finders of fact?

Actually, it isn't. If your locality defines public exposure to a minor as a sex crime, and someone drunk walking home from the bar makes the bad decision to urinate in public, and it gets written up as "indecent exposure" because the DA is trying to crack down on homeless people and had sent a memo to throw the book at public urination cases, and a 17 year old is known to have been present so the prosecutor uses that fact... well, then its a sex crime. Period.

That's the issue - there is generally no "common sense" allowed. Which is actually better than the alternative, since if there was you'd almost certainly see it applied grossly unevenly. But still, the answer to your question is, "Not really."

And as for your headline, "Belittling Sex Crimes", I think the real issue here is that as far as lifelong punishment goes, we're treating sex crimes as more severe than multiple homicides. Even a murderer, once they've paid their debt to society, is free with nothing more than a criminal record. Nobody's saying that sex crimes aren't criminal, but surely you have to draw the line somewhere? Aren't there a lot of crimes that are, arguably, much worse?

Or (acknowledging hyperbole) will we end up encouraging rapists to kill their victims if they think they're likely to be accused and recognized, because presumably consensual sex followed by murder carries a lesser burden? That can't be right.

Most Active Letters Threads

438

Do Obama officials know what his Afghanistan plan is?

What explains the completely contradictory statements from key aides on a central plank of the war strategy?
408

America's regression

It's almost impossible to find a nation with as many torture advocates as the U.S. has.
332

Palin: Birthers have "fair question" about Obama

Of Obama birth, the ex-governor says, "the public is still, rightfully, making it an issue" (Updated)
109

Is my kids making me not smart?

Stay-at-home fatherhood dulls my intellect to a nub. Excuse me while I ponder the subtext of "Hippos Go Berserk"
99

I survived Glenn Beck's Christmas spectacular

The preposterous showman brings his holiday book, and waterworks, to the stage and screen. Lights! Camera! Jesus!

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon