Letters to the Editor
jared2
Published Letters: 223 Editor's Choice: 16
-
Rejigger
[Read the article: Ask the Pilot]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]"Rejigger"
Thanks, Patrick, for a new word. (I already knew "rejig")
As for the absurdity of checking pilots and not cleaners, that horse has been dead so long there's nothing left but bones to flog.
-
Seven years?
[Read the article: I Like to Watch]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]"Seven years I watched Tony Soprano do his thing, and for what?" said Minneapolis lawyer Sal McAllister, "All he is to me now is some asshole bully."
I had him and all the rest pegged as "asshole bullies" in seven minutes, after which I had no interest in the show. Mediocre acting, writing - what a bore.
-
We are not meant to be here; we insist on being here
[Read the article: We are meant to be here]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]"For many of us it seems, it is inconceivable that the miracle of human existence is a random accident. For some reason, the randomness, the accidental-ness (if I can say that), negates meaning for these poor unimaginative souls"
Meaning and purpose are human categories that have evolved to help us survive. Man can intend to go to the moon, but the moon does not intend to go around earth. To say "we are meant to be here" implies that something outside humans - "God" or "the laws of the universe" wanted to create us. Man creates meaning and purpose as survival tools. Man created God as a survival tool. But no God or law of the universe "wants" us to exist - our will to exist comes from ourselves. Life started accidentally, but we are the product of millions of years of evolution, in which organisms have the sole purpose of surviving to pass on their genes. What started accidentally has now been shaped by millions of years of purpose-driven evolution. Meaning is therefore founded on meaninglessness, like the painting of the church floating hundreds of feet above solid rock. That meaning is, at root, meaningless in no way detracts from its value. In fact, it leaves us free to construct whatever meaning we wish for human life. If it were not this way, we would be slaves to some God or some non-human purpose.
-
Laws of the universe
[Read the article: We are meant to be here]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]I fail to see any connection between "the laws of the universe" and meaning and purpose in human life. The moon goes around the earth, the earth around the sun, the sun converts hydrogen into helium - all according to laws of the universe, but these have nothing whatever to do with meaning or lack of meaning in human life. There is simply no connection. We need the sun's energy to exist, but the sun does not shine for us. All life, including human, is simply a photo-chemical byproduct of processes like light energy from the sun acting on the earth's surface. Our sense of purpose comes from millions of years of intense evolution which has the survival of our genes as its sole purpose. Where did this will to survive and reproduce come from? Probably it is a feature of the evolutionary process itself. A self-sustaining chemical reaction. There is no need whatever for "God" or "purpose". I suspect that millions of years of evolution in which we have the strong "purpose" to survive shaped our thinking so that we feel everything must have an ultimate purpose; this is not the case.
-
Pandering to New Age Nitwits
[Read the article: We are meant to be here]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]The headline says it all - "We are meant to be here". Unless, of course, an astoroid just happens to hit earth next week and destroy all life. In that case, we were not meant to be here.
-
smallpkgs
[Read the article: We are meant to be here]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]Thanks for your letter which is not only true, but elegant.
-
An excellent overview of this subject
[Read the article: We are meant to be here]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]I just finished "The Meaning of Life" by Terry Eagleton. I strongly recommend it. He goes into Aristotle, Schopenhauer, Beckett, Marx, Wittgenstein, as well as Buddhism, Taosim and Christianity. He does so with considerable humor. It is not a terribly long book, considering the subject. I won't give away his conclusion, but it mirrors what I said in previous posts, which just goes to show how smart he is.
-
Self-help
[Read the article: Does self-help breed helplessness?]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]The day I look to Oprah or a self-help book for advice is the day I will beyond all help, having descended into senility or dementia.
-
AC is an American obsession
[Read the article: Air head]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]I completely agree with you about over-reliance on AC. It is almost always overdone, especially in this country. In my sealed building workplace, I freeze. In malls, I freeze. I live in a suburban house and we leave the windows open all summer. We love to feel the breeze coming in, the sound of the wind in the trees. We are shaded by large trees, so it doesn't get that hot. It isn't a matter of nostalgia - its a matter of wanting to feel the air circulating naturally and wanting to hear natural sounds. If necessary, we turn on fans. It feels good to sweat a little and feel the evaporation from the wind. The only problem with having our windows open at night is listening to the inevitable whine of the neighbor's central air, which, typically, is on even when it's 75 degrees. I much prefer the sound of crickets, which, toward the fall, will easily drown it out.