Letters posted here are associated with the following Salon Premium Member:

Bukk63

Published Letters: 642
Editor's Choice: 64

Tuesday, February 3, 2009 08:28 PM

Charles wins!

I also said I'd root for whichever quarterback painted Matt. 6:5 on his cheek black and then lived up to it. Like that's ever gonna happen. Not that they're liable to care about whether a hellbound type such as myself roots for them or not.

Subtracting the snark, I stand by the rest. Warner has a striking story and a few great seasons, and we can get all warm-and-fuzzy about that. Even I, with zero patience for all the rapacious bible thumping, love his story. But when he was down, he was way down. You can't ignore how bad he was when he was bad, nor for how long. (Doesn't mean you can celebrate his great moments.)

So, amazing performer at times, but not a HOF career performer.

As for the officiating, well, there are ways the NFL can quash this kind of talk. Stop sucking at officiating. Even if it didn't affect the outcome of this game (and I'd agree probably not), it still was sub-standard. It didn't used to be like this, not this consistently bad. I mean, sheesh, it's something every weekend now, not just the Super Bowl.

Monday, February 2, 2009 03:14 PM

Doh, WILL admit, WILL admit

In that last letter, I meant to say a Steelers-hater such as myself WILL admit admiration for that final drive, etc. etc. Gah.

Monday, February 2, 2009 03:12 PM

The problem with the officiating

Even if you're right, and even if you're wrong, the fact that the argument exists suggests something important about the NFL brand. It's eroding, and it's eroding at least in part because the spectators are increasingly distrustful of the quality of the officiating.

Used to be, of all the major sports, the one thing that seemed certain was that NFL officials were professional, fair, and supremely competent. What seems to be the case now is that the competence is vanishing, the professionalism with it, and there's a sneaking suspicion that the fairness is starting to vanish as well. When it comes to the officials, the NFL is starting to look more like the NBA. (Now, to be fair, the NBA lost me a few years ago, and for all I know the current officials are no longer a hyper-emotional crop of ego maniacal prima donnas spoiling for a fight.)

I'm not much of a sports follower anymore, mostly because the the way the business of sports has become more important than the sport itself has turned me off. But I've stuck with the NFL longer than the others, and a lot of that has to do with the sense that zebras were fair and damned good at their jobs. I'm not so sure anymore, which has contributed to my decreasing interest.

Yesterday's Super Bowl had, I think, poor officiating. Not Super Bowl XL poor, and not Ed Hochuli "I blew it" poor, but pretty weak. That can't help but taint the product. Now, I don't think the officials "handed" the game to the Steelers, and I don't think there is any way to say for sure the outcome would have been different had they been more competent. But I can't be sure. I dunno. Would not calling that joke of a roughing the passer penalty have changed the shape of that drive? Would consistent holding penalties and unsportsmanlike conduct penalties made a difference? Who can know?

Given what they had to work with, in the end, the Steelers won, and even a committed Steelers-hater such as myself won't admit grudging admiration for that final drive, and in particular, that game-winning catch.

But as someone who used to live for the NFL, I wish it could have happened without so many questions, questions that have grown in recent years.

Monday, February 2, 2009 07:23 AM

Coupla other thoughts

Enough folks have commented that James Harrison's 100-yard interception return is now the greatest Super Bowl play ever that a retort seems necessary. No, Tyree still holds that title, as exciting and unlikely as Harrison's return was. In the Tyree play, everyone did everything they could, made no mistakes, and the crazy thing happened. Even Rodney Harrison, who covered Tyree on the play, admitted as much in the pre-game.

James Harrison's interception depended on Warner making a boneheaded throw. After that, hell, yes, he not only caught the ball but beat tackles for a hundred yards, but if Warner doesn't make a mistake, the play never happens.

Tyree wins not just on spectacle on the fact that it was just a damned amazing football play in which everyone involved played balls out and made no mistakes.

As for Warner in the HOF, I mean, seriously? I know there was talk of that in the build up to this Super Bowl, but wasn't it all just feel-good claptrap? The guy has had a few amazing seasons and has a striking story, but he's mixed it up with some real dogs. Even if the Cards had won, he hasn't had a HOF career. Too much chaff with the wheat, as his type would say.

Monday, February 2, 2009 07:10 AM

You knew the officiating would be bad

When the NFL announced the team, with that guy from the Titans/Ravens game at ref, I thought, "Great. We're fucked." Impossible to say if it made a difference (though that roughing the passer call was a joke, especially considering the crap that guy let the Ravens get away with), but in the end the Steelers did what they had to do take the game back from the Cardinals. Ben more than made up for his nervousness in his last Super Bowl and Holmes earned his MVP summa cum laude.

Kudos to the Steelers, and that's hard for me to say. I mean, damn, I hate the Steelers, but they did it, six now. Good for them and gratz to their fans.

Sunday, February 1, 2009 07:42 PM
Original article: "Obsessed with children"

I'm with Benny

Mrs. Duggar is frighteningly reminiscent of the Terry Jones mother from Monty Python's Meaning of Life "Every Sperm Is Sacred" bit. Stepford is downright homey in comparison to the Duggar freakshow.

My question: has TLC (aka What The Fuck? Television) signed up Nadya Suleman yet?

Most Active Letters Threads

359

A key British official reminds us of the forgotten anthrax attack

A vast array of establishment and expert sources do not believe this episode was really resolved.
323

Tough-guy John Bolton, hiding under his bed

As usual, right-wing pseudo-warriors are drowning in extreme cowardice.
188

Is Obama's civil liberties record understandable?

Was it unreasonable to expect him to adhere to his commitments regarding the Constitution?
154

Phil Carter's resignation from key detainee policy post

Many of the "War on Terror" policies he spent years condemning were ones expressly embraced by Obama.
99

Palin, Prejean: Beastly treatment for beauties

The governor turned author must fight what the pageant queen learned: Politics and hotness make strange bedfellows

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon