- Top Features:
- War Room
- Glenn Greenwald
- Broadsheet
- Joan Walsh
- Camille Paglia
- Since You Asked
- Follow Salon:
Read other letters about this article
Seriously, you cannot tell me Nirvana was an insignificant musical blip, unworthy of mention compared to the New York Dolls.
How about Heart? They are still vastly underrated. No, not their 80's junk, but their early stuff.
The Doors anyone? CCR? Santana? Pearl Jam? peh! Weak, marginal west coast fluff? That is what NY music critics to this day would have you believe.
And BSH (before Sammy Hagar) Van Halen was groundbreaking for their time. There is a reason VH is one of the top selling artists of all time-- yet you hear snot nosed asthmatic scrawny black jeans wearing NY writers constantly disparaging VH, probably because the band had never played CBGBs.
How many records has Lou Reed sold on the other hand? two, three thousand?
Sure, selling records is not the be all, end all. Talented artists I have liked that sold relatively few records have included The Mavericks/Raul Malo, Low Fidelity Allstars and Lone Justice (sure, sniff at them, why don't you).
When NY music writers DO focus on the West Coast, they tend to write about degenerate, small change novelty acts like the Donnas.
You are right. I am not an 'expert' on music. I know what I like to listen to, I know some or much of it is sniffed at by know-it-all writers called 'Nigel' who eat and breathe obscure crap bands 24/7/365. But so what? Who said music should be masochistic, like memorizing baseball statistics?
All this overanalysis of music and lionization of certain bands misses the BIG PICTURE. As Louis Black, founder of South by South West, put it recently, in the seventies, when he was a music snob, he listened to a bunch of fringe artists, but for some reason despised Led Zeppelin. Well, as he got older, he realized he was not seeing the forest for the trees, missing the fact that Robert Plant had an incredible voice and delivery.
This is how little I think of most music writers-- what with their unnatural cultic fixation on the same tired marginal acts. You can just hear the drone. The same damn list of saints iterated over and over and over, everyone has had it engrained in their skull by now how 'significant' all these stupid-artists-nobody-really-listens-to are supposed to be.
Husker Du
the Replacements
Wilco
Elvis Costello
Radiohead
Bob Dylan-- yechhh
Rufus Wainwright
Yeh, I'm naive, like a kitten.
I am glad to be a musical simpleton, who likes stupid dunderhead acts like Simple Minds, Oasis, Alison Krauss/Union Station, Nickel Creek, Smashing Pumpkins, Sarah McLachlan, Foo Fighters, Arcade Fire and U2. All of them, every damn one to the last, a fraction of the talent of a damned Wilco.
