Letters to the Editor

"Cloverfield" Do we really need the horror of 9/11 to be repackaged and presented to us as an amusement-park ride? By Stephanie Zacharek [2008-01-18]

• Exactly

  I'm sure 9/11 did have an effect on the production of this movie. That is, everyone was instantly educated on 9/11 as to what effects a collapsing building would produce in NYC. To have collapsing buildings NOT look like that would be what, willful ignorance for the sake of some weird sentimentality for the horrors of that day?

  This is right. In a bizarre way, 9/11 itself was life imitating blockbuster. Most people seeing what actually happened, either first hand or in the endlessly looping TV images couldn't help but compare it to Independence Day, Armageddon, or any of the numerous disaster films of recent memory.

  For the first time, we have a visual vocabulary of what a destroyed NYC would really look like. If you're trying to make a gritty, realistic take on a giant monster movie, made from a firs t person perspective, there's no way you can ignore that.

  -- creepo
  [Read creepo's other letters]
  Permalink Flag Friday, January 18, 2008 05:12 AM
  Click "Submit Flag" if you feel this post is inappropriate. Explain why below if you wish.

  Cancel