Letters to the Editor

This letter is associated with the following article:
Salon writers and special guests weigh in on their favorite performances and movies of the year -- and the ones they couldn't stand.
  • I'd rather see "Sack Lunch"

    Thank you, thank you, thank you, (....thank you) Anne Lamott for knocking "Atonement" down a notch on the critical praise-o-meter. This film started out on such a promising note but devolved into a mess of stilted dialogue, bludgeoning visual metaphors, and pointless tracking shots.

    A smart filmmaker would have chosen to make the movie all about Paul Marshall and Lola, the comely red-headed coquette. The scene where he instructs her to "bite hard" on a piece of candy was one of my favorite moments in any film this year and was a thousand times more erotic than that little bit of ugly bumping in the library.

    Also, this film was unable to disprove my suspician that Keira Knightley is, in fact, a 16-year old anorexic boy.