Letters to the Editor

Letters posted here are associated with the following article:
All quiet on the gay western front Not wanting to give their foes free publicity, right-wing Christian groups say they won't boycott or picket "Brokeback Mountain."
The letters thread is now closed.
  • High-LAIR-ee-us

    Oliver Stone thinks that bisexuality ruined "Alexander"? That's so funny! I've invented a drinking game around "Alexander". Players must drink whenever:

    1. Angelina Jolie, playing Count Dracula, rolls an "r" so violently that you can almost see the camera shake.

    2. Colin Farrell's eyebrows change color or show considerable grow-out.

    3. Colin Farrell's hair changes color or shows considerable dark roots.

    4. Colin Farrell's chin quivers before he bursts into tears.

    5. Colin Farrell lusts after some man/tranny/woman-who-he-thinks-is-a-wild-animal.

    Players should not attempt to play this game using hard liquor (I recommend beer), or players will be drunk within a matter of minutes.

    Simpering, unrequited bisexual lusting was the least of that movie's problems. And hell - if the male characters had gotten to act upon that lust, I would have enjoyed it! There would have been no need for the drinking game.

    It's funny that this movie, Brokeback Mountain, is aimed at women. For weeks, my female coworkers and I have been making lists of the Hollywood actors that we'd like to pair up. I think they hit the nail right on the head - we're suckers for some guy-on-guy action.

  • a beautiful story

    I first read Proulx's story Brokeback Mountain several years ago and thought it was a beautiful, moving love story. It doesn't begin as a story about gay cowboys, but, rather, the characters discover their love with each other. That's part of the beauty of the story. I'm sad that this essential plot twist is no longer to-be-discovered for folks who haven't read it.

  • "It's possible to have total comfort with AND total lack of interest in something."

    And this is why every single straight man alive will never see this film? If you were reaching any farther, you'd hurt your back.

    Somehow, being queer hasn't stopped me from seeing a few thousand movies about the joys of heterosexual love -- something I have total comfort with AND total lack of interest in.

    It's a movie. I don't have any interest in being an astronaut, the Devil, a 1950s housewife, Hannibal Lecter, President of the Unted States, a giant radioactive dinosaur, or a gazillion other things I could name. But I've seen movies about all of them. Who sees only films that are about people just like them?

    Besides that, how many straight men have to write testimonials in this letter column before you accept that your, shall we say, aesthetic prejudices aren't shared by all straight men?

    We get it: you want all straight men to not be interested in the lives of gay men. It's not true, you have no real-world reason for believing it's true, but you'll never stop saying it is true. Fine. Straight men are still going to see this film, anyway, you can go on pretending otherwise, and everybody's happy.

  • Ghost of Westerns Past?

    'But Knight is really fired up about the affront to the ghosts of westerns past: "I think this shows that Hollywood can pervert anything. Part of the enduring appeal of westerns is the display of brotherhood, unhindered by sexualization. ... The western was a morality tale, so to make immorality the heart of this western is to violate the code of westerns. That's why it's not going to work." '

    This passage suggests that Christians like Knight understand neither the strength of Christianity's critique of social structures nor their own attachment to American mythology. The genre of the western is neither sacred nor inherently Christian; it is an American genre that reflects American ideas. Christianity, like Judaism before it, takes the mythologies of the nations it inhabits and turns them inside out. So for Knight and Co. to be upset about that BBM inverts the genre shows they are more deeply wed to the American mythos than to Christianity.

    And as for Sandy Dixon, someone should inform her there are enough gay cowboys to make up a gay rodeo circuit....

  • WR Christianists and fantasy?

    I'm related to one of these Christianist nutjobs, and she does not allow her kids to have anything to do with any sort of fantasy, from Smurfs when they were younger to a movie with the word "Witch" in the title. There are plenty like her who believe that all fantasy is the work of the devil, whether written by C. S. Lewis or not.

  • great year for fantasies

    I look forward to both Narnia and Brokeback Mountain...

    The latter? Sure, I shall enjoy it on both an intellectual and emotional level, but the shallow part of me says, "hello. I SO can't to see these guys make out!!" I know it's hard for some of you to fathom, but chicks DO like to see guys get it on.

    That Knight is so damn smug, isn't he? Does he know anything about the fantasy genre and sexual awakenings in young girls? I've always been a big sci-fi/fantasy geek, and it was a huge influence in my sexual development (I'm not sure if the chicken or the egg came first in this respect).

    I just recently joked to some friends that, with the releases of both Harry Potter AND Narnia, 2005 is shaping up to be an awesome year for horny 9 year olds.

  • Narnia and gay cowboys

    I am a 30-something, heterosexual woman--and a Christian (on the liberal end). I have been looking forward to seeing both of these movies for some time. I saw a BBC version of LWW from many years ago and thought it was interesting. It's only been recently, as an adult, that I became aware of its Christian symbolism. That isn't the only thing interested about LLW, however. I have enjoyed Lord of the Rings and the recent Harry Potter movie. What's wrong with some fantasy and talking animals? I also saw the preview for Brokeback Mountain sometime ago, which peaked my interest. Then again, I like several of Ang Lee's movies, and have seen plenty of movies about gay men. I find it amusing that some people, because of their own homophobia, can be in such denial about the reality of gay cowboys. The reality of gay cowboys or any group of people isn't dependant upon whether people approve or not.

  • Actually straight men do have an interest in the lives of gay men

    they are interested in how easy it is for them to get laid so often with so many different partners for so little effort under any conditions and on their own terms. What they are not interested in is the actual gay relationship. I think if you actually bring yourself to examine this interest honestly you will see that I am right.

Most Active Stories

Read More

Letters Help

Daily Delivery

Salon headlines in your mailbox