Letters posted here are associated with the following article:

175
Letters
Thursday, January 25, 2007 12:00 AM

Herbivore vs. carnivore

Are vegetarians the moral, peace-loving, cruelty-free enemies of the meat eater? Or a bunch of kooks living in la-la land?

The letters thread is now closed.

View:
Friday, January 26, 2007 04:24 AM

intelligence and predators

I also notice that, with a few exceptions, the most intelligent animals are all predators. This makes sense.

Not really. Even pack hunting is setting a really low bar for intelligence. Meat sharing and pack behavior begin to develop higher cognitive functions for effective social interaction, but the top tier of intelligent traits are social/empathetic in nature.

Slow child development and nurturing learned skills, complex morality and empathy for group dynamics, inventing/using/teaching tool use and cultural traits etc.

Studies show the great apes have complex and highly empathetic social skills with an emotional range that is approximate to human.

Unfortunately, most people know almost nothing about our ape relatives, so the examples people take from nature tend to be unintelligent.

Several ideologies such as ruthless Social Darwinian and it's close relative Fascism are greatly inspired by predatory pack behavior, and consume themselves quickly. For example, many of the brightest scientists tend to be humanitarians, Universities are humanitarian by nature. The Fascist brain-drain of WWII tipped the balance with brain work such as code breaking, physics, engineering, etc.

Predatory practices like Enron's, Big Tobacco, many rent based segements, colonialism, etc; all have moments of great success but see diminishing returns over the long haul as society develops greater moral intelligence. Predatory behavior is ultimately a dead end in human evolution.

Friday, January 26, 2007 03:33 AM

Have it both ways....

All this talk of food is making me hungry. So, tonight, we're going to our favorite beef restaurant where I will have a salad, a loaf of bread, the 16-oz. prime rib, plenty of side veggies, a couple of nice beers, and some sort of luxurious dessert and coffee.

If that isn't well balanced, I don't know what is!

P.S. For those who say the meat part of my diet will shorten my life, I can only say....

With an idiot in the White House and global warming already beginning to make our lives miserable, who but a masochist would *want* to live longer?

Thursday, January 25, 2007 11:09 PM

Meat eating has nothing to do with fear

I could care less what anyone thinks of my dietary habits, it's simply none of their business.

But then again, I've never "in a moment of weakness, lost control and raged at or become physically rough with a child."

I've also killed animals, skinned them, butchered them, then eaten them. Many many times.

It's food, and it's no different than reaping wheat or shucking corn.

No do I nor most people I know suffer "similar feelings of regret, remorse, “wrongness”, and a recoiling from the destruction of something living and sentient."

Most animals aren't sentient, very very few mammals, much less any other type of animal are even aware of self. This is demonstrable. Outside of great apes, dolphins, sea cows, and a few select others, animals can't even recoginze themselves.

This doesn't mean they should be abused or made to suffer needlessly. Nothing bother a true hunter like than a suffering animal.

You don't personally want to eat meat, that's fine with my. I simply don't care, but when you start talking about how those of us who simply reject your choices must be somehow overcome with fear, you've crossed the line.

Vegetarianism is a religion to many, and they try to force their religion upon others in the same annoying manner than many relgions do.

Neither I nor most care about your religious vegetarianism.

Thursday, January 25, 2007 10:58 PM

Hitler was a vegetarian in the latter part of his life

Hitler wasn't a vegetarian.

It's an urban legend that he was a vegetarian. While I appreciate your attention to vegetarianism, couldn't you please have checked your sources before making such a statement?

---------------------------

The fact checking needs to be done by you, and others claming that Hitler was not a vegetarian. He simply in fact was, and it's not even a debated point.

We have many records attesting to his rather silly nature of trying to force his brand of vegetaranism on his inner circle, we even have records of conflict between his chefs and others about how to cook food.

While Hitler wasn't a vegetarian for the majority of his life, that's because he became a vegetarian after his niece died in the early 30s. Hence, for the period of time that he is most know, except for win he wrote Mein Kampf, he was a vegetarian.

This has nothing to do with the morality of vegetarianism.

And yes, I'm aware of Mr. Blue and his wholly unfounded arguements. They have no basis in fact.

Thursday, January 25, 2007 09:53 PM

Hitler wasn't a vegetarian.

It's an urban legend that he was a vegetarian. While I appreciate your attention to vegetarianism, couldn't you please have checked your sources before making such a statement?

Thursday, January 25, 2007 07:47 PM

meat eating is fear-based

Ambiguity and ambivalence around the choice of killing and eating animals versus vegetarianism arises because we avoid the direct experience of taking life and/or we escape the associated inner experiences.

Analogously, almost all adults have, in a moment of weakness, lost control and raged at or become physically rough with a child. In a healthy individual the immediate reaction involves feelings of deep regret, remorse, and a drive to avoid future incidents. Adults who have developed a capacity for empathy and autonomy use the experience constructively to change their behavior.

Those of us who have killed animals directly and hands-on know the response shared by all humans: similar feelings of regret, remorse, “wrongness”, and a recoiling from the destruction of something living and sentient. But as children, especially males, growing up we are domesticated not only to kill, but to kill those inner emotional experiences that would otherwise honestly and directly inform our choices. We are domesticated to kill off, to disallow, a part of self connected with empathy and control of aggression.

Ultimately – and profoundly ironically – what keeps us from accessing those inner experiences and from choosing not to kill, not to engage in the manly, virile habit of carnivory, is fear: fear of choosing authentically, fear of inner experience, and most of all fear of rejection by those whose approval and acceptance we become dependent on.

Bottom line: if a meat-eater could authentically and honestly access and report to us his or her inner experience around the possibility of becoming vegetarian, we would hear something like this:

“Yeah, right, like I’m gonna tell the gang at work I’ve become a vegetarian the next time we go out for burgers. Can you imagine? Or at Christmas dinner with Mom and Dad and everybody? The looks I’d get? No way could I do that."

"I’m afraid to.”

Most Active Letters Threads

530

Do Obama officials know what his Afghanistan plan is?

What explains the completely contradictory statements from key aides on a central plank of the war strategy?
408

America's regression

It's almost impossible to find a nation with as many torture advocates as the U.S. has.
332

Palin: Birthers have "fair question" about Obama

Of Obama birth, the ex-governor says, "the public is still, rightfully, making it an issue" (Updated)
128

Is my kids making me not smart?

Stay-at-home fatherhood dulls my intellect to a nub. Excuse me while I ponder the subtext of "Hippos Go Berserk"
126

Trig, the anti-abortion straw baby

Sarah Palin's son is being used to demonize pro-choicers

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon