Letters posted here are associated with the following article:

6
Letters
Tuesday, April 18, 2006 12:00 AM

The original mad scientist

The 16th century alchemist known as Paracelsus was a drunken, foul-mouthed coot -- and the unlikely father of modern medicine.

The letters thread is now closed.

View:
Tuesday, April 18, 2006 04:42 PM

Fascinating...

Yet the book fails in one regard. We get an idea of how horrendous life was in early Europe in the 16th century, however, this does not give us an idea of the world as a whole as it related to medicine.

At the time when most of Europe lived in hovels, squalor and experiencing rampant disease, the Africans, Chinese and Arabians lived in comparative splendour. They were the ancient Phoenicians, the Astronomers, the originators of Math, and herbal, i.e., natural medicine.

This book also fails to mention, although much of history has been lost in that regard, the role of "wise women" , healers and mystics, who, largely were destroyed for having the "heretic" power to restore life. Also, in Scotland many female priests were healers, and mediators, before the Catholic church (and Rome) tortured and killed most of them to rid the church of such an "unnatural" office.

Additionally,many of those who died of such diseases in Europe were the peasants.

Although this book deals largely with one man, I would have preferred seeing much more of where his ideas of medicine came from - since we now know that travel, however long and arduous, took place quite frequently than once supposed.

Tuesday, April 18, 2006 03:53 PM

Cosgrove's a great reviewer

made me want to run out and buy the book even before i finished his review - give this guy more space !!

Tuesday, April 18, 2006 02:46 PM

Terrific review

I hope the book is half as good...

Tuesday, April 18, 2006 12:44 PM

No scientist there

Wait a second. You cannot call this man a scientist, mad or otherwise. He believed in the four humors, gave medical attributes to plants based on anthropomorphising them, meaning if it looks like a human organ, then that plant can be used to treat that organ. If he cured anyone of anything, it was probably because that person had a spontaneous recovery based on his own immune system.

The closest he came to science was when he theorized about a single circulatory system. Before then "medical science" thought there were two from seeing the different colors of arterial blood and venous blood. But he did not establish this by cutting up cadavers.

He was like the other doctors of his time talking about humors, and giving astrological archetype attributes to parts of the body, and feeding people mercuric oxide (cinnabar) as a treatment. Insulting the nonsense medical writings of Hippocrates, Galen, or Ibn Sina (Avicenna) or the town authorities did not make him a scientist.

This book sounds like a hagiography of a "bad old boy." I would not read it based on this review.

Tuesday, April 18, 2006 09:09 AM

The Science of Origins I

Chemistry began

With cooking, not alchemy;

Measure, mix and heat.

Monday, April 17, 2006 08:38 PM

Superior to Celsus, maybe, but ...

I think either Ball or Cosgrove has it wrong when translating Paracelsus as "superior to Celsus" - my reading of the name would have it "equal to Celsus". One could say that that was no less arrogant a self-assessment, grant you, but somehow it seems more in line with his love of reason.

Otherwise I look forward to a good read ...

Most Active Letters Threads

530

Do Obama officials know what his Afghanistan plan is?

What explains the completely contradictory statements from key aides on a central plank of the war strategy?
408

America's regression

It's almost impossible to find a nation with as many torture advocates as the U.S. has.
332

Palin: Birthers have "fair question" about Obama

Of Obama birth, the ex-governor says, "the public is still, rightfully, making it an issue" (Updated)
128

Is my kids making me not smart?

Stay-at-home fatherhood dulls my intellect to a nub. Excuse me while I ponder the subtext of "Hippos Go Berserk"
126

Trig, the anti-abortion straw baby

Sarah Palin's son is being used to demonize pro-choicers

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon