Read other letters about this article
The most common names in England has Catholic associations for pete's sake. There's nothing particularly papist about Sophia--a name that means "wisdom" and thus in keeping with the Puritan tradition of virtue names. As for "Dooley" being Irish--that doesn't preclude it from having WASP associations. The Irish upper classes were Protestant and there's a *long* tradition of Anglo-Irish intermarriage among Protestants and thus Gaelic names.
I have to say as a WASP, myself, Ms. Schwartz' fabulist take on my tribe is just kind of peculiar.