Good article.

Is thoughtful, well-researched, discourse and superb writing no longer a criteria for Salon editorial?

If I wanted this kind of sensationalized journalism, I would pick up a tabloid at the supermarket checkout.

So long, Salon.

The American Idol producers must be loving the publicity all this is generating.

Without the wacky balance that Simon, Paula, and Randy create together as a judging group, the show wouldn't be the same. It's pop music. It's fun to see Paula emote. It's fun to see Simon acid-tongued. It's fun that Randy's comments are both predictable - and not. The recipe won't work as well with different ingredients (and a fourth judge - just unnecessary and too time consuming for a live show - we all know if we like a performance or not - viewers just want to see one of the judges say what we are thinking or feeling after watching; we're not looking for high-minded critiques).

It's a little like when a certain iconic American cola mix formula was messed with years ago ... none of it's particularly good for you, but if you're going to indulge, go with the classic mix. I hope the show will keep Paula Abdul (despite her manager's publicity antics), and that the unique chemistry of this American Idol judging panel will play on.

He's quick and funny a lot of people like his sense of humor. Ease up, Salon -- let's at least see his show at 10 before you review it.

You and Opus are the best. Here's to the sweet dreams in all of us ...

... why isn't this the lead story at the top of the Salon daily page instead of "Zombie Feminists of the RNC"?

Both are important, but it would seem that the abysmal failure of the administration seven years later ought to get top billing today of all days.

Director P.J. Hogan (Muriel's Wedding; My Best Friend's Wedding) made an absolutely enchanting version of J.M. Barrie's PETER PAN. The cast sparkles, and the visual and story nuances are so gorgeously presented that I've no idea why this gem didn't get more attention when it was first released. Definitely an often overlooked treasure for children of all ages, and especially the grown-up children! Enjoy ...

Obama has integrity. I wish I felt as sure about the integrity of whatever editorial intent underlies this article. It's well written, but the slant does not seem entirely worthy of the perspective or depth that made me a Salon subscriber in the first place. Salon had the vision to create a new media, weaving together great writers and detailed research into a unique focus that would help change for the better the way we view the news and define the issues facing our times. Obama is trying to do the same thing, creating a new vision and leading the way to restoring America's integrity and the principles on which our country was founded. To encourage Salon readers to dig deeper and really read all of the ample information on each candidate's policy positions and records is admirable. Perhaps that is what Salon had in mind, but this article seems to have been crafted more in service to a provocative headline, rather than framing or highlighting important reference info mentioned in the posts.

Obama's track record shows that he isn't afraid to fight and work hard for what he believes in. He gets what America is worried about, and understands the hopes for the future, as well as the way the world works. Obama leads by example and follows through on his convictions, which are quite clear.

Yes, I'm cheering for Obama. I'm also cheering for Salon to not let this kind of vaguely pointed article become the norm in their political coverage. We're all interested in what's going on right now in Iowa and how people are deciding to vote, but please give us more of what this article only touched on - stories in voters' own words - rather than offering more of the usual rhetoric about the rhetoric, which is part of what has made the traditional media less relevant and unnecessarily cynical. Please keep blazing new discussion and journalism trails, Salon, without sacrificing your own status-quo-changing core. Allowing courageous, offering-something-different talent and committment to be so casually cast in a nebulous light, giving sway to a "skeptical feeling ...", does not illuminate or inspire confidence in your trusting readers. America needs you, Salon, and all the bright stars of hope and integrity it can get.

... are so much brighter with the new galaxy of Opus fun. Thanks, Salon. Thanks, Berkeley!

Thanks for bringing Opus to Salon–my new Sunday morning paper. Love your funny and wry Sunday smiles that last all week (and then some!).

This is a swashbuckling romp - a summer swagger of over-the-top adventure that matches the serendipity of saga, silliness and seriously high-octane action that the first two movies celebrated so well. Check your saber-edged cynicism at the popcorn stand - we could all use a journey on a wide-open sea of imagination, heroic hijinks, and swaths of visual and verbal repartee as a respite from our own "... weird and haunted shores..." where hangin'-by-a-thread democratic ideals, international in-fighting, and big business as the ultimate pirate is an all too familiar story!