Letters posted here are associated with the following Salon Premium Member:
Published Letters: 1016
Editor's Choice: 13
The Palin Problem.
NewsWeek Article, click on the link below.
Palin is on the ticket because she connects with everyday Americans....
But that honest explanation of the rationale for her candidacy—not her preparedness for office, but her personality and nascent maverickism in Alaska—raises an important question, not only about this election but about democratic leadership. Do we want leaders who are everyday folks, or do we want leaders who understand everyday folks? Therein lies an enormous difference, one that could decide the presidential election and, if McCain and Palin were to win, shape the governance of the nation.
...
Palin sometimes seems an odd combination of Chauncey Gardiner from "Being There" and Marge from "Fargo."
...
Is this an elitist point of view? Perhaps, though it seems only reasonable and patriotic to hold candidates for high office to high standards. Elitism in this sense is not about educational or class credentials, not about where you went to school or whether you use "summer" as a verb. It is, rather, about the pursuit of excellence no matter where you started out in life. ... This is much less evident in Palin's case.
...
there is no arguing that McCain is qualified to be president of the United States. But there is plenty of argument about Palin's qualifications. Why should we apply a different standard to the vice president who would stand to succeed him?
...
We have been here before. In 1970 a Nebraska senator, Roman L. Hruska, was defending Richard Nixon's nomination of U.S. circuit Judge G. Harrold Carswell to the Supreme Court. An underwhelming figure, Carswell was facing criticism that he was too "mediocre" for elevation. Hruska tried an interesting counterargument: "Even if he were mediocre, there are a lot of mediocre judges and people and lawyers. They are entitled to a little representation, aren't they, and a little chance? We can't have all Brandeises, Frankfurters and Cardozos." Fair enough, but it still seems sensible to aspire to surpass mediocrity rather than embrace it.
...
But she is not seeking a Senate seat, nor is she being nominated for a cabinet post, and so it is only prudent to ask whether she is in fact someone who should be president of the United States in the event of disaster. She may be ready in a year or two, but disaster does not coordinate its calendar with ours. Would we muddle through if Palin were to become president? Yes, we would, but it is worth asking whether we should have to. What do we know about Palin after, as she put it with a wink, "like, five weeks"? That she can be a superb political performer (she held her own against Biden, projecting an image of warmth and toughness) and she can be a poor one (too many questions in the debate went completely unanswered, and the Couric interview is full of moments no candidate would like to have out there).
...
Remembering how John Edwards had brought his own staff to the ticket with John Kerry in 2004, creating immediate and lasting tensions, the McCain camp wanted to exert complete control over their running mate. Schmidt and others assembled a team of well-known Republican hands for the veep squad. The campaign pointedly did not hire anyone from Palinworld.
...
Larry Persily, a former Anchorage Daily News editorial-page editor, left the newspaper in May 2007 and worked as an associate director in Palin's Washington, D.C., office until June 2008. He says he left on good terms—Palin offered him another job when he resigned—but he believes she is not qualified to be vice president and is speaking out for that reason. He describes Palin as an easily distracted manager.
Could we 'muddle through' with her as President? I certainly hope so.
One thing is for sure, with her and her husband's history of attacking people that have dissed her, I wouldn't want to be Tiny Feh on a dare under a Palin presidency...
One thought: Is that why they aren't afraid of a strong Vice President? (They could act like the city manager of Wassilla, part of her much touted 'executive experience') Who would that be if McCain dies and Palin is president? Speaker of the house? I expect an executive order to change that coming up soon, before January 20th and the political situation in Congress is known...
Anyone see the article where McCain declared that he had Latin American foreign policy experience because he dated a Latin American woman? Yeah, you betcha. And how was Ireland and Iraq, there, Sarah...
Wasn't it Ashcroft that said that 'America needs another attack'.
Of course it backfired in Spain but, it was Spain... ;-)