Letters to the Editor
Published Letters: 4 Editor's Choice: 1
-
Another sad fan of the movie-musical
[Read the article: "The Producers"]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]As someone who loves musicals, I feel like I have been waiting for years for the return of the movie-musical. I was first excited by Moulin Rouge, with it's campy glitter, and when Chicago followed, I was sure something good was coming. The line of poor adaptations that has followed Chicago has me very upset. Not only because it means that I am not getting the beautiful movie-musicals that I so desire, but because all of them are working from such great stage productions. The source materials are for the most part very good, but the adaptations seem unwilling to take the artistic chances to translate the shows apropriately to film.
To me, this seems to tie to an observation that Stephanie Zacharek made in her review of King Kong - that movie companies are looking for sure-fire hits these days. As opposed to taking a chance and maybe writing a musical for film, of seriously rewriting a show so that it will take more advantage of the medium, all of the shows that have come out recently are things that are HUGE hits, have won major awards, and have tremendous fan bases. So to buy into the success of the original, the film-makers seem to, for the most part, just do a straight production of the show. Both Phantom and Rent had little things they did to make the plot flow more linearly - flashbacks, montages, cross-country road trips. But these things just bogged the films down in facts, losing some of the soul of the shows. Combined with other elements of stage productions that will never translate well to film (unless you just film the stage show, stage and all), these adaptations have all seemed to take their original and maim it.
I haven't seen The Producers yet, but I was already worried, and now I am even more so.
Next they'll make a film of Wicked. Wait and see how bad that can be.
-
Something missing?
[Read the article: The Great Santino]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]We don't get any of Santino's Tim Gunn impersonations? Because really, the part where Andrae and Tim are having a fight at Red Lobster was one of the season's highlights for me. (Though the song & dance about fashion was lovely too.)
-
Come to University City!
[Read the article: Let's have a revolution! Does July 14 work for you?]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]I can't stop sending people this article. Because somehow, Anne has managed to pick the two things that I never doubted the importance of, the truth of. Kindness and libraries. These are keys. Green is good, too.
Yes, all you naysayers, specific action is important too. So is voting your values.
But that doesn't stop this from being an amazing idea. A picnic. To discuss our dissatisfaction with the current administration, wherever that dissatisfaction stems from. To meet people we might not otherwise meet. All because we can agree on the importance of kindness, and libraries, and that this administration is not doing things quite right. And out of this find a little bit of the unity that we've been losing, little by little, all these years.
You can't do it all at once. This is a good start.
I, for one, am organizing a group at the University City Library in University City Missouri. I'll have cookies, and strawberries, and mangoes. And I will be happy to hear whatever you have to say. Come on your lunch break - that's what most people I know will be doing. Noonish.
-
Seriously
[Read the article: What a way to make a living]
[Read more letters about this article: Here]Is there any way we could lobby Dolly Parton to keep a blog? Because I would read it daily. As would so many others. The other 9 to 5 women are wonderful also (and it IS a great movie, which I may have to buy soon...), but really. Dolly's such a hoot. And she has something (semi)wise to say about everything.