Letters posted here are associated with the following Salon Premium Member:

LauraBB

Published Letters: 448
Editor's Choice: 79

Monday, July 2, 2007 05:44 PM
Original article: I Like to Watch

Big Love shows what a Big Waste polygamy is

I am stunned and amazed that anyone thinks this show is somehow showing polygamy in a positive light.

Barb and Bill obviously have an enduring affection and attraction for one another that is 'outlawed' by the polygamous situation they've set up for themselves. It's not only shorting out big time on the potential their relationship had to sustain themselves and their children throughout their lives.

Nicky is frustrated and unhappy, obviously not cut out for the inferior position she finds herself in as second wife. She is doomed - along with her whole family - to a life of underhanded manipulation and deceit.

Margene is lonely. She is a sweet girl who could have been very happy in a mutual loving relationship with a young man her own age. They could have had friends and a social life. She is obviously isolated and lonely. Every time you see her at home one of hte kids is in the playpen and she is just sitting there.

Bill's life is filled with useless stress and pressure.

The whole arrangement seems pathetic and wasteful of potential and happiness.

Monday, July 2, 2007 08:09 PM
Original article: We are meant to be here

Yawn - disappointing article

An elegant explanation? I don't think so. About as original and derivative as 'The Secret' - although I don't think Oprah will be embracing Paul Davies.

The more physicists scrabble around splitting theological - oh sorry I mean scientific - hairs over how we came to be here, the less I respect them. These questions: What am I? How did I come to be here? Why am I here? are at the heart of all philosophy and theology - and science too if it feels like it. To pretend otherwise - that no this is not a religious argument, this is a scientific one, calls into question what exactly 'scientific' then means. He's quoting St Augustine at the same time as he's saying he doesn't want to talk about God for Christ's (sic) sake! (query: unless there's some other Augustine he's mentioning here?)

It's all conjecture. And when you compare the conjecturings of guys like Paul Davies compared to science fiction writers, Paul and his ilk come off a very poor second.

It's time these guys actually got off the fence that they're ever more precariously perched upon and embraced the search for meaning - meditation, looking within - or embraced their imaginations and, if they can pull some kind of entertaining story out of it, started writing fiction.

It all reminds me of string theory and what a load of fashionable, incomprehensible and irrelevant bollocks that's turned out to be.

Tuesday, July 3, 2007 09:57 PM
Original article: The Hillary and Bill show

An outsiders perspective

I'm an Australian and here on the North Coast of NSW we are celebrating July 4th, Independence from American Day. It's more of a hope than a reality - as in the last few years we have seen the signing of a Free Trade Agreement with the US that many Australians were opposed to, and Australian participation in the Iraq war that millions upon millions of Australians came out to protest against in unprecedented numbers. Still, of course, our Prime Minister kowtowed to your President and we're there.

I remember when Bill was president - people liked America. I don't have stats for that, but I remember the feeling in the air. And not just here in Australia. Elsewhere I lived during his presidency - in India and the UK, and travelling in Europe, I and my friends, my 'demographic' really, felt good about the USA and friendly towards it. My husband worked in an American firm in London and even though we found 'you' strange in some ways - incredibly hardworking and serious about doing so, amazingly obsessed with shopping - it was overall a good fit. There was a tonne of respect.

Fast forward - no one I know speaks of America with anything but contempt bordering on fear. I was in New Orleans on business a few months before Katrina and I was dumbstruck and frightened by the poverty I saw there. Yet when I tried to tell my American colleagues about it - that yes in fact it WAS on a par with what I had seen in India and other parts of the third world - they didn't want to hear it. Well, who would?

America these days has an image of an Imperialist, out of control, barely legal state. It was scary enough when Bush stole the election, but things have spiralled so badly down from there.

I KNOW none of this is the fault of anyone I know. I KNOW all of this horrifies fellow Salon readers much more than it does me, becuase you LIVE there.

What I have to say though is this: if Hillary Clinton were to win the Presidency I think internationally it would win America an enormous second chance. Unlike any other incumbent, who would have so much repair work to do before they could even start going forward, she would be given a free pass on a lot of things, both because so many of us around the world already 'know' her, and because of Bill.

If the 'Rest of World' as we're so nicely named in US marketing terms matters a jot, then Hillary for President is the one to go for.

Most Active Letters Threads

369

A key British official reminds us of the forgotten anthrax attack

A vast array of establishment and expert sources do not believe this episode was really resolved.
205

Is Obama's civil liberties record understandable?

Was it unreasonable to expect him to adhere to his commitments regarding the Constitution?
104

How dare you criticize wasteful defense spending!

So you think it's only terrorist-appeasing lefties who are down on Pentagon profligacy? Think again
70

The crazy, irrational beliefs of Muslims

Tom Friedman explains the real problem: stupid Muslims think the U.S. is about war and aggression.
51

Police to talk to Woods

Early morning crash raises questions, and revives tabloid speculation

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon