Letters to the Editor

Letters posted here are associated with the following Salon Premium Member:

jdsmith

Published Letters: 19     Editor's Choice: 1

  • Oh, fuck me

    [Read the article: For Harry Potter fans about to rock, we salute you]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Bring back AudioFile.

  • Diction error

    [Read the article: The three stooges]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Stooge means "idiot lackey." Cheney is nobody's "stooge." He is the boss. If anybody is the thrid stooge, it's Bush--although Cheny treats the rest of America as if we are all his stooges.

  • Where do I get "Franny and Alexander"?

    [Read the article: Beyond the Multiplex]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Bergman does Salinger! Wow!

    (Or did he already do it and call it Hannah and Her Sisters?)

  • A misunderstanding of what critics do

    [Read the article: "The Bourne Ultimatum"]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    If they are worth a damn, critics hardly ever tell you if they "liked" or "disliked" a work. Critics' job is to describe in such detail that you know what the film (or book, or television show, or and-so-on) is about and how the artist approaches the topic aesthetically. If you need a consumer guide, you can use criticism, but you have to put in some effort of your own when you approach the critics.

    BUT, if you are looking for a thumbs-up, thumbs-down reduction and learn that 92% (92%!) of reviewers approve, you might want to give the movie a chance.

    (How can you mistake Zacharek's review for anything less than kudos?)

  • P.S. I am not a republican.

    [Read the article: Cheerful boos for Hillary]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Poco: One word in the following sarcastic sentence belies that claim.

    "Not one story about the amazingly effective democrat congress."

  • yay! Now he'll be gone, like Karen Hughes was gone, forever and ever

    [Read the article: Karl Rove to resign]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    And he'll be so happy to see his wife and kid that he'll never, ever show up on CNN to "discuss" politics.

  • You knows he's snickering about this

    [Read the article: Remembering Karl Rove]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    He thinks that he got away with it.

    Deep in his heart, perhaps he thinks that, since he's getting out unindicted, he's a winner.

    Somebody should remind him, though: no matter how much a myth he was or is or ever will be, he's no Lee Atwater.

  • Oh

    [Read the article: Gore for the Nobel? How about Petraeus?]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    So that's where the Weekly World News reporters are working now.

  • So. Does somebody have something he'd like to say about the Coens?

    [Read the article: TV Daily]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    I mean, something that's coherent.

  • "female John McCain supporter"

    [Read the article: Quote of the day]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Linda Burke, of Hilton Head, SC.

  • Where's Thadeus Crumb's apology?

    [Read the article: "The Golden Compass"]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    End of message.

  • "The only points he scores are with Brave New World and 1984--both of which were novels."

    [Read the article: "We're all fascists now"]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    What has the genre of those works to do with their usefulness in supporting or rejecting arguments?

  • Here's an idea

    [Read the article: Clinton has "Girlfriend posse" to thank?]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Let's put Marianne Pernold Young and Linda Burke--the woman from Hilton Head, SC, who asked McCain how to beat "the bitch"--into the same coffee shop this time.

    (Why have shitty little restaurants become the Marketplace of Democracy?)

  • "The fug of complacency"

    [Read the article: The battle of the literary endorsements]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Laura Miller's typo is as inadvertently brilliant as Maya Angleou's (in)famous "dried tokens of their passing."

  • Well said, Blue Bunny

    [Read the article: What I really wanted to say to Chris Matthews]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    I am surprised that more people don't get the point that Michelman inadvertently makes: that you should not expect a do-over if you are a grossly inept feminist (or anti-war, or civil rights) pundit.

    "I didn't expect Chris Matthews to be so mean to me"? Fucking terrific.

  • JackWOrf is the funniest thing I have read lately

    [Read the article: Palin releasing medical records -- or not]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Whoever he is, he has the rant of the looniest Republican down pat (except that he takes it too far sometimes--e.g., the "Sieg Obama" overkill).

  • Isn't this a line of attack from the last debate?

    [Read the article: McCain camp: "He made us go negative"]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Didn't it go flat last week?

    Or was it that there was so much media goodness in Joe "Jumped the Shark" the Plumber that the McCain crew have been saving it for later?

  • Don't let Laura Miller's endorsement turn you off

    [Read the article: "Serena"]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Rash is the real deal, an excellent poet and short story writer who has written a great novel (One Foot in Eden) and two very good ones (Saints at the River and The World Made Straight) before this one. Serena, with its grand and sometimes bizarre gestures (the eagle, the one-handed henchman), is both greater and lesser than One Foot in Eden (though it, to be sure, also had a witch of its very own). The difference is that the earlier novel is quiet, assured, and respectful of its audience's feelings, whereas Serena is balls-to-the-wall operatic from page 1.

    He's the best writer working in and about the mountain South today, a geography I hate specifying since it will, in some readers' minds, limit his abilities and aspirations, as well putting him into a category they needn't bother with. So let's change that to: One of the five best novelists working today.

  • Excellent, Salon

    [Read the article: The economic Civil War]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    You have found surefire troll bait to go along with Camille Paglia and the articles about God that start so many roaring flame wars.

Most Active Stories

Read More

Letters Help

Daily Delivery

Salon headlines in your mailbox