Letters to the Editor

Letters posted here are associated with the following Salon Premium Member:

Jim Tourtelott

Published Letters: 7     Editor's Choice: 1

  • A Song of Peace

    [Read the article: Toronto Film Festival]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    In 1900, Jean Sibelius completed the symphonic poem Finlandia, which contains a hymn-like section popularly known as the Finlandia Hymn, which Sibelius later published separately. It is often played on public occasions in Finland, but is not the Finnish national anthem.

    In 1934, Lloyd Stone wrote A Song of Peace, setting his verse to the Sibelius melody. A Song of Peace has been popular with church groups for many years, and appears for example in the hymnal published by Friends General Conference. Yes, Quakers sing. One Quaker who sings is Joan Baez, who has had A Song of Peace in her repertoire for years.

    As it happens, I already knew these facts when I read Ms. Zacharek's snarky crack. But I can assure you that, by simply using the Google, a person who read that sentence and said to herself, "Why the hell would anybody not terminally silly sing the Finnish national anthem at an American political rally?" could discover most if not all of them in under ten minutes. Ms. Zacharek didn't ask that question, one presumes, because it was already an article of her faith that Joan Baez is an ass.

    Who's silly now?

  • Do you have a corrections policy, or not?

    [Read the article: Toronto Film Festival]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Friday afternoon, Ms. Zacharek referred to Joan Baez "warbling her way through the Finnish--yes, Finnish--national anthem." I sent you, and you posted, a fairly long and I trust reasonably cogent letter explaining that what Ms. Baez was in fact "warbling" was the rather well-known hymn A Song of Peace, whose melody is taken from Finlandia, which is not "the Finnish national anthem." On Monday, poor Joan is still, in Ms. Zacharek's copy at least, confused about what country she's in.

    Put simply, on Friday that was an error. Today, it's just a lie.

  • Cianci

    [Read the article: What's in a bat-crap-crazy name?]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Cianci is a fairly common surname in Providence. (Indeed, one of Providence's better-known mayors was named Cianci.) Unfortunately for her, a young woman with that surname who graduated from my high school a few years before me had the otherwise quite conventional name Nancy Ann.

  • The person who best fits these criteria

    [Read the article: What Obama needs most]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Can be a good attack dog and hammer John McCain.

    Offers a working-class, rank-and-file appeal to those parts of the coalition with whom Hillary Clinton thrived.

    Potentially delivers a state.

    Is strong in policy areas where Obama is not.

    Even if he formally took himself out, the person who best fits this set of criteria is Webb.

  • The New Republic

    [Read the article: The decay of serious journalism and Rachel Maddow's new show]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    It has been impossible for any literate person beyond the generations of toadies and lick-spittles Martin Peretz has hired over the years to take The New Republic seriously for at least the last quarter-century.

  • It's not quite so new

    [Read the article: Nepotistic succession in the political class]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Leaving aside the Adamses, Harrisons, and Roosevelts, consider a single woman--still alive at this writing--Bethine Clark Church. Her husband, father, uncle, and cousin were all at one time or another Governor of or Senator from Idaho, and if her older son hadn't decided to finish his seminary studies (as he tells in his recent memoir) he might have been a Congressman from Nebraska. Gore Vidal says somewhere that before he was injudicious enough to publish The City and the Pillar, the wires were being pulled for him to follow his grandfather into Congress.

    Still, I admit that one thing that persuaded me to support Obama was the grim notion of an unbroken 24 or 28 year period when the names of the President were Bush, Clinton, Bush, Clinton. That's no way to run a republic.

  • On using one's name

    [Read the article: Birthers get a big new supporter]
    [Read more letters about this article: Here]

    Some pinhead asks "By what legal means" Barack Obama gets to call himself Barack Obama.

    Well, let's see. I get to call myself Jim Tourtelott because my father, Jim Tourtelott, named me Jim Tourtelott.

    It's really that simple. Honest. No need for a Grassy Knoll, or 15 foot tall extraterrestrial lizards, or the Elders of Zion. If your dad's named Barack Obama, he can name you Barack Obama, and that's your name.

Most Active Stories

Read More

Letters Help

Daily Delivery

Salon headlines in your mailbox