Letters posted here are associated with the following Salon Premium Member:

pacificwhim

Published Letters: 660
Editor's Choice: 39

Sunday, November 2, 2008 06:57 AM
Original article: McCain gets mean

Total cultural amnesia

What I find hilarious and disturbing about some of the letters posted here and elsewhere is how the vilest, most destructive or most dictatorial acts of the Bush administration, the Neocons and the GOP are being redirected as "what we can expect" when Obama takes the oath of office.

Destruction of our freedoms under one-party totalitarian rule? Yeah, that's precisely what Bush tried to accomplish with warrantless wiretaps and the FISA bill, the PATRIOT Act, approving torture and having the NSA spy on and harass anti-war groups like the Anti-War Grannies from San Francisco. The intended 100-year Republican reign intended by Karl Rove, together with the policy of the unitary executive, would have had us living in a dictatorship in 10 years, had it not self-destructed under the weight of its own incompetence.

Economic wreckage? With their penchant for deregulation, their givebacks to the oil companies, their total neglect of schools and infrastructure and their castigation of science, the Republican Party has left us with a shattered economy and a broken foundation with which to rebuild it——namely, an undereducated populace that doesn't understand basic science, and an outdated electrical grid and factories that can only produce obsolete products. Way to go, GOP! And you're worried that Obama's going to come along and somehow do more damage by regulating things?

As for the cries of socialism...capitalism is an exceptionally successful system when it is properly regulated so that a) Those who create the wealth with their labor benefit to the same proportion as those who own the companies, i.e., you don't work for 20 years to build a company and then have your job shipped to India; and b) companies do not degrade the environment or the economy with illegal practices (dumping of toxins, default credit swap trading, etc.). Like personal freedom, capitalism and free markets are not absolute. You don't have absolute freedom in our country. you cannot walk up to me and punch me in the face without going to jail, and you can't publish something scandalous and false about me without being sued for libel. In the same way, markets can't do whatever they want; they require oversight and government involvement, and to some that is socialism.

But if you want socialism, as many have pointed out, just look at our current government handouts to AIG, the auto makers, and $700 billion in capital infusions to banks. That's as close to socialism as we get, folks, much closer than Obama's intent to return us to a progressive tax code. You remember that, right? Where the people who make more also pay more? Remember, the Bushies were also the cats who wanted to dismantle the best example of successful socialism this country has ever seen: Social Security, which has helped tens of millions of seniors survive in retirement (anybody know if John McCain has sent back his Social Security checks?). If Bush and the GOP and their banker buddies had had their way, the system would have been dumped into the open markets and managed by financial services companies—you know, the markets that are currently melting into slag and the financial services companies that are setting new standards for incompetence and corruption. Apparently, it's more important——more ideologically pure——to dismantle something that smells of "socialism" and works pretty well than it is to leave it alone and solve some of our other problems. But then when big GOP donors like Wall St. investment banks are about to go under, socialism is a big happy party with smiley balloons.

In sum, everything you folks accuse Obama of being about to perpetrate when he takes office (except for the 250,000 troops, which is just too batshit insane for comment) are depredations that Bush and the Republican Party have already visited upon this country in their incompetence, ideological insanity and greed, bringing us to the brink of economic receivership, intellectual bankruptcy and international irrelevance. The fact that some of you actually have the gall to accuse Obama of being about to bring on the exact horrors that the Republican/Neocon cabal has foisted on us these last 8 horrific years means you either a) have mastered the art of turning someone else's argument on themselves, such as accusing a girlfriend of cheating when she's the one who caught you in bed with the nanny, or b) you're completely delusional and unable to face the truth that the supposedly "America first," God-and-country party and its smirking frat boy figurehead have led the nation down the darkest eight-year rat hole in its history. John McCain has shown himself to be completely beholden to that party's ideals of war, tax breaks for the rich, and smear campaigning. Do you honestly think he'd have a single original idea to get us out of the messes we're in?

I don't think Obama is a saint. I don't think he's the messiah. He's a politician. What is it about him that makes people so excited? Maybe, just maybe, it's because he's young, hip, dark skinned (like so much of the country is now), well-spoken, and doesn't give off the creaky, fearful vibe of the rest of the political field. The guy doesn't seem like a Washington glad-hander. Also, he's brilliant, a marvelous orator, and has managed for the most part to stay away from character based attack politics. He makes people feel hopeful about voting again, like they're not just voting for the lesser of two evils.

Obama may not be all these things, and he may end up being as big a disappointment in the White House as the Democrats were when they took over Congress in 2006. I don't have a crystal ball. But I would rather take my chances with someone who MIGHT BE a great president and a transformational leader than with the certainty of John McCain, who WILL MEAN four more years of ugliness, war, homophobia, ignorance and attacks on the Constitution.

Most Active Letters Threads

685

Obama's exceedingly familiar justifications for escalation

The "new" approach to Afghanistan touted by White House officials seems quite old
599

The commendably missing element from Obama's speech

There was no pretense that human rights is our goal, or the likely outcome, in escalating the war
440

The face of rotted Washington

Evan Bayh demands more debt-financed war - fought by others - while boasting that he's a stern "deficit hawk."
317

Yes, it's Obama's war now

An uninspiring speech sells a dubious policy, but progressives who feel betrayed have only themselves to blame
209

Bigotry wins in Switzerland

By voting to ban the construction of minarets, Switzerland apes the most extreme intolerance in the Muslim world

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon