Letters posted here are associated with the following Salon Premium Member:

Tentakles

Published Letters: 3
Editor's Choice: 1

Monday, July 2, 2007 10:42 PM
Original article: We are meant to be here

What is the meaning and purpose?

I'm sorry that Paulson didn't follow up on the part of the interview that he / the editors obviously felt was most important: that the laws of the universe "grant our lives meaning and purpose." Hearing Davies explicitly say what the purpose of the universe is would have shed quite a bit of light on his argument.

Even if one accepts Davies' particular model and an algorithmic interpretation, it doesn't automatically lead to any meaning or purpose beyond that.

There are plenty of systems that develop in a very predictable (algorithmic) way: orbital mechanics, radioactive decay, stellar evolution, formation of stalactites, etc. What is the meaning of the beta decay of rubidium-87? What is the purpose of red giant stars? If components of the universe can develop without purpose or meaning, why should the universe itself possess either?

Unless I missed something, Davies' hypothesis only requires that the universal quantum state inevitably gives rise to observers. It doesn't automatically confer meaning or purpose. The need for those things seems to be a property of people like Paulson and Davies.

In facing up "to the fact that there may be fundamental limitations just from the way our brains have been put together," Davies should consider that one of those limitations might be the emotional need for meaning and purpose that colors our search.

Friday, February 22, 2008 04:14 PM
Original article: "Vantage Point"

chaotic events

"Just once I'd love to see a depiction of chaotic events edited with slow, painstaking precision."

I'd say Peckinpah's "The Wild Bunch" meets that criteria

Saturday, July 12, 2008 12:10 AM

If you're going to list Fantasia...

You should at least give a shout out to the excellent non-mouse alternative "Allegro Non Tropo". The evolution sequence set to Bolero is fabulous. The live action slapstick between the animation sequences are witty and lampoon Disney. I don't recall any scenes scarier than "Night on Bald Mountain", but it is more mature in theme. As befits an Italian movie there are religious references and it certainly casts a jaundiced eye on humanity. Okay maybe it's for tweens and above.

In the European animation vein there is "The Triplets of Belleville". Mobsters, music, and the Tour de France.

Certainly anything by Nick Park - especially "The Wrong Trousers".

Oh, what about "Holes"?

Most Active Letters Threads

736

The commendably missing element from Obama's speech

There was no pretense that human rights is our goal, or the likely outcome, in escalating the war
688

Obama's exceedingly familiar justifications for escalation

The "new" approach to Afghanistan touted by White House officials seems quite old
329

Yes, it's Obama's war now

An uninspiring speech sells a dubious policy, but progressives who feel betrayed have only themselves to blame
325

America's regression

It's almost impossible to find a nation with as many torture advocates as the U.S. has.
192

The poster boy for progressive self-delusion

Read Hayden's 2008 Obama endorsement to remember the way the left sold our centrist president to itself

View all »

Letters Help

Currently in Salon